If you rank 6th for a keyword, Google already considers your page relevant to that query. Pushing an existing page up a few spots is usually a shorter road than writing a new page and trying to break onto page one. That is why SEO teams love this list: keywords that are on the first page but not in the top 3.
The problem is that the list tends to be long. You cannot improve hundreds of keywords at once. This post covers how to pull the list from Search Console and how to decide which ones deserve your time.
Pull the list from Search Console
Open the search results view of the Performance report, set the date range to the last three months and turn on the average position column. On the Queries tab, filter the table by average position: greater than 3, less than or equal to 10. What remains are the queries on the bottom half of page one.
It matters how average position is calculated. According to Google's Search Console help page, the topmost position your site held is counted for each query, and that value is averaged across all queries where your site appeared. So 7.2 is an average, not a fixed rank. A keyword may have sat at 3rd for half the month and at 12th for the rest. Open the keywords you are unsure about one by one and look at the daily chart; if it zigzags, the problem is stability, not rank.
Read the query together with its page
Click a query and switch to the Pages tab. If two of your pages alternate for the same query, Google cannot decide which one to show. In that case, strengthen one of them first and link the other to it, or merge them. Improving both separately often keeps both at 7th.
Looking from the page side shows something else too: several near-top-3 keywords often cluster on the same page. If one page update can lift five keywords, that page moves to the top of your list.
Which ones are worth pushing
Ask four questions for every keyword left on the list. Write the answers in a table and the choice becomes clear on its own.
- Volume: are the impressions meaningful? Moving a query with 30 impressions a month to 3rd looks good in a table but makes no difference to traffic.
- Intent: how close is the searcher to your product? A query looking for prices, comparisons or a solution is worth more than one looking for general information.
- Competition: who holds the top 3? Overtaking competitors of similar size is possible. If big marketplaces, encyclopedias or government sites hold the top three spots, the effort is high and the odds are low.
- Results page layout: search the query yourself. If ads, an AI Overview, videos or a shopping box sit on top, 3rd place can land below the fold and not bring the clicks you expect.
Make a rough estimate of the gain
To take the choice out of gut feeling, produce a rough number for each candidate: monthly search volume times the difference between the click-through rate at the target position and at the current one. The number is not exact; it is for ranking candidates against each other. A high-volume keyword at 7th often promises more than a low-volume keyword at 4th.
For click-through rates you can use the curve from a general study, or derive one from your own Search Console data. The second is more reliable because it reflects your own market.
What to change on the page
Open the top 3 pages and put yours next to them. Usually the gap is a missing subheading, an answer buried in the middle of the page, or information that has not been updated in years. Answer the query's question directly in the heading and the first paragraph. Add the subtopics competitors cover and you skip.
Link to this page from the strong pages on your site, with anchor text that describes the query. Rewrite the title tag around the query; even if the rank does not move, the click-through rate can.
Measure the result, not a single day
Note the date of every change. Then compare two periods of equal length before and after the change: average position, impressions and clicks. Hitting 2nd for one day is not a result; ranks move within a day and between days. A keyword that stays below 3rd for four weeks has moved to a different list.
Looking from the competitor side helps too. If the competing page in the top 3 was updated while you were working, the effect of your change mixes with theirs. For the overall setup of tracking competitor moves systematically: How to do competitor analysis
With Adversee
Adversee's SEO module regularly reads the Google rank of your own site and your competitors for the keywords you track. The near-top-3 card lists keywords ranking 4-20, sorted by the estimated click gain of reaching 3rd, and shows who currently holds the top 3. No gain is written for a keyword with unknown volume, and the card states on its face that the figure is an estimate.
Start tracking competitor moves automatically.