The raw list you get from a backlink tool mixes two kinds of rows: links an editor placed on purpose and links no human placed on purpose. Analysis that skips filtering the second group misleads. Your link gap list fills up with directories, and a competitor's link profile looks stronger than it is.
This post separates two jobs that often get mixed up. The first is cleaning for analysis: which domains should leave the list. The second is what to do about bad links pointing at your own site. The answer to the second is usually shorter than people expect.
How Google defines link spam
The spam policies page on Google Search Central defines link spam as creating links to or from a site primarily to manipulate search rankings. Some of the examples on the page:
- Buying or selling links for ranking purposes, including links in exchange for money, goods or services.
- Excessive link exchanges and partner pages built only for cross-linking.
- Links created with automated programs or services.
- Links from low-quality directory and bookmark sites.
- Links spread across the footers or templates of many sites.
- Forum comments with optimised links in the post or signature.
The same page accepts that buying and selling links is a normal part of the web's economy. Paid links qualified with rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" do not violate the policy.
What should leave the analysis list
Cleaning for analysis is a filter; you are not penalising anyone. If two or more of these signs appear together, drop the domain or move it to a separate tab:
- The domain links to thousands of different sites and its topic has nothing to do with yours.
- Pages look auto-generated: they copy other sites' text or only list domain names (site worth or whois style pages).
- The link sits in the footer or sidebar and repeats on every page.
- The page's language and country are unrelated to your market, and it gets no search traffic.
- The anchor text is a meaningless string of exact-match keywords.
- The domain belongs to the competitor's own network: same group, same template, same contact details.
The last one is not spam, but it has no place in an outreach list either. A competitor's sister site will not link to you.
A spam score is an estimate
Most backlink providers give each domain a spam score. Using it for a first pass makes sense, because you cannot open thousands of rows one by one. But the score is the provider's own model, not a value Google uses, and two providers can score the same domain differently. A local news site with few links can score high, and a well-run link network can look clean.
A practical setup: set aside the high scores automatically, sample the middle band by hand, and keep the low scores. Write down your decision for the domains you checked manually, so you do not reassess the same domain next month.
Keep domains with no readable score separate too. A missing score does not mean the domain is clean, only that it is unknown.
Bad links to your own site: do you need to disavow
Google's help page for the disavow tool recommends it when two conditions hold together: you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site, and those links have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. According to the page, in most cases Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, and most sites will not need the tool. It also calls the tool an advanced feature that can harm your site's performance in Search if used incorrectly.
So seeing a few hundred scraper sites in your backlink list is no reason to prepare a disavow file. Check the Manual actions report in Search Console first. If there is no action there and nobody bought links in the past, Google says it can assess these links without your guidance.
If links were bought in the past, or an agency ran a bulk link campaign, it is a different situation. The help page says the first and most important step is to get those links removed from the web. Disavow is the next step for links that cannot be removed.
Make cleaning a standing step
If filtering stays a one-off job, you will meet the same domains every month. Keep your decisions in a domain-level list and apply it first on every new read. What to do with the cleaned list is covered in our post on link gap analysis.
With Adversee
Adversee shows each domain's spam score in the link gap list and does not count domains with a high score as link candidates. The domain detail view also shows the number of broken backlinks and the weekly spam score. If the provider could not return a score, the cell stays empty instead of showing a low score.
Start tracking competitor moves automatically.